10 points for each of the items I, II, III, IV and V. Total is out of 8 points (total / 50 * 8) I. Details on progress made since development report II. Problems and solutions III. Principles used IV. Details on Patterns V. Report overall MedicAid: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 7 Not enough details provided on this. V. Report overall 10 Total (47) 7.52 Student Testing System: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 10 V. Report overall 10 Very good organization of the report on how the forces behind a change, or application of a certain principle or pattern is presented. Good job on that. Also presented details on D' value improvement and showed NUnit tests. I like that. This team not only delivered excellent report, they also submitted the report at least 24 hours in advanced consistenly for each report. Job well done. Total (50) 8 SyndiSnag: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 0 V. Report overall 10 Adequate coverage of problems and principles. No coverage of patterns however. Total (40) 6.4 Bug-base: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 10 V. Report overall 10 Forces behind implementation Workflow factory and other solutions presented well. I am not a fan of Merging files. However, you have mentioned effective steps and tools to do just. I as curious and will take a look at that tool :) Good report. Total (50) 8 Wheels.com: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 8 V. Report overall 10 Adequate discussion of problems and solutions presented. Not enough information on the use of patterns presented though. Total (48) 7.68 MunchRSS: I. Details on progress made since development report 10 II. Problems and solutions 10 III. Principles used 10 IV. Details on Patterns 7 V. Report overall 10 Presented details of problems faced and principles used. Adequate coverage to details. Some patterns addressed, but not enough on patterns though. Total (47) 7.52